Theory doesn’t always align with reality...which is why we call theories “theories.” That’s the case for dividend irrelevance theory fo sho.
Dividend irrelevance theory says that, in theory, a company’s dividend policy shouldn’t affect a company’s stock price/value at all, since investors can respond to what’s happening with dividends (going up or down) accordingly. These two guys argued that shareholders aren’t, like, “locked in.” For instance, if dividends go up, investors can just reinvest that money, and if dividends go down, investors can just sell some of their shares, using that money elsewhere to get the money they planned on getting from the dividend.
Basically, they argue that dividends don’t add value, because investors can put that money elsewhere...where it’d also be making money.
Yet, there have been a lot of super-academic studies on this, and they show that dividends do indeed increase the price of stocks, especially for high-end blue chip stocks. So...it seems like dividends are perceived by investors as icing on top, even though they could get their icing elsewhere with that same money...in theory.
Related or Semi-related Video
Finance: What is an Accumulated Dividend...9 Views
finance a la shmoop what is an accumulated dividend okay you know what
a dividend is companies generally commit to paying it when they have so much [Example of dividend meaning on a 100 dollar bill]
extra cash profit that they really don't know what to do with the dough yeah nice
place to be in the case of a preferred stock the dividends aren't just a
optional-ish they operate more like bond interest only with a catch
that is dividends on preferred stock can in fact be halted without the company
being repossessed by the debt holders like in the case where the company falls [Prize wheel lands on hard times]
on hard times or it wants to preserve its cash to buy a competitor or it just
wants another jet with a water slide thing on it well yeah it can halt its [Person slides down a jet slide]
dividend in those cases and well there are two types of preferred stock in this
realm the ones that pay cumulative dividends and the ones that don't
cleverly named non-cumulative say a company has halted dividends from its
preferred for three and a half years and it was paying five bucks a quarter in [Dividend distribution graph]
dividends from those cumulative preferred well if it was to resume
paying dividends on them it would first have to pay all back fourteen quarters
worth of dividends before it began to issue more dividends or pay them to its
preferred holders that is it owed three years times four quarters or twelve
quarters plus half a year or two quarters for a total of fourteen
quarters at five bucks a quarter a share that's five times fourteen or seventy [Formula of non-cumulative dividends]
dollars a share in back cumulative dividends big obligation but it has to
pay that amount before it can resume dividend payments why would a company
have a cumulative feature in its preferred dividend obligation well
because investors forced it to do so or they wouldn't invest they were worried [Person swipes away stacks of money]
that the preferred dividends might be just some merrily stopped and then the
investors would have little or no return on their investment in the preferred and
this can be a problem for companies that have fallen on hard times they are
essentially made illiquid in that they can't afford to pay the back dividends [Example of illiquid meaning]
on the preferreds and they can't raise more capital with this blight on their
record of having stopped paying a divvy well most [Non cumulative stock stickers appear on a table]
furred stocks are non-cumulative and if companies decide to just stop paying
them they can but if they do it's kind of like they've reneged on a handshake [Two guys giving a handshake]
and you know investors talk so like good luck to the company ever trying to raise
capital again from the cold cruel outside world yeah welcome to Wall
Street [Wall Street road sign]
Up Next
What's a dividend? At will, the board of directors can pay a dividend on common stock. Usually, that payout is some percentage less than 100 of ear...
How do you calculate rates of return? Calculating rate of return on an investment that pays dividends can be a bit tricky. You need to look at the...
What is the Dividend Discount Model? Valuation of stocks can take numerous forms. One way in which one perspective on undervalued stocks is determi...