Transaction Risk

  

Categories: Insurance

Whatever.com has extra cash. It can pay a dividend. It can buy back its own stock. It can buy a competitor.

Example:

Cendant Corporation. Largest fraud case in modern history in corporate America. The company, which owns rental cars and office space and insurance things and travel things, had a nice "subscription-like" business. It wanted more growth. So it bought CUC (Comp-u-card), one of the early AOL partners who used Groupon-like discounting to market to subscription members all around the world. The transaction was done as an MOE, or Merger of Equals, as the market valuations of both companies was about the same at the time.

The problem? CUC was only actually "worth" about 1/5th of the valuation it had convinced Wall Street to accord it, because it had taken massive merger reserves while it had built its own business over time. That is, it grew by acquiring tons of small companies, overstating the banking and "restructuring costs" (i.e., firing people). That number kept growing and growing on the balance sheet, and investors kinda just ignored it.

Eventually, when the real audit was done, the chickens came home to roost (and poop all over the place), and it came clear that the company was only about 1/3 as profitable as it said it was. So the stock prices of the combined companies went from somewhere in the mid $40s to middle-single-digit-midget status.

And yes, there was massive transaction risk there. For way less money, Cendant (which had no fraud) could have bought back half of its own stock and been just fine as a company...but they took the risk and got bitten. Bad.

Related or Semi-related Video

Finance: What is Event Risk?6 Views

00:00

Finance a la shmoop what is event risk risk risk risque er yeah,

00:09

how'd that get in here all right moving on investing carries all kinds of risk

00:14

inflation risk is a biggie for those who like to buy safe government low-interest [100 dollar bill inflates]

00:19

low risk paper yes their investments always pay back but while they only get

00:23

like 2% kind of returns and in a world of 3% inflation well that's a big

00:28

problem well then there's market risk too [S&P 500 graph appears]

00:31

stock markets go up and down all the time so yes over time they go up but

00:36

well you might own stock in a great company that in a bad market gets taken

00:40

down like all the other boats in the ocean when a big quake hits and suddenly

00:45

it's a tsunami time and well everything drops but historically if you hold good [People in discussion at a meeting]

00:49

companies long enough well well their high quality bails you out of any

00:53

short-term losses you've suffered so if these are normal risks that happen all

00:58

the time they're things that just go on and on it's all part of the investing

01:02

world then what's an event risk which implies that something happened there

01:07

was a vent there was a finite period of time a finite situation that made bad

01:12

things happen with the overhang that events you know like a solar eclipse or [Solar eclipse appears]

01:17

or the election of a smart ethical congressman well those don't happen all

01:22

the time that's an event right it's a one-time thing well here's an event a

01:25

meteor hits the earth and all of a sudden while the most prized possessions [Meteor strikes earth]

01:30

are simple things like water and gas and land with wood and animals yeah that's

01:36

an event well the value of your Amazon and Netflix stock in that case well

01:40

those companies are probably not worth whole lot cuz internet is probably

01:44

dead or at least injured so when wizened old investors invest they typically [Old investors appear holding stock]

01:50

think about "once in a lifetime" events with event risk as being

01:56

a risk that they have to account for and yes thinking about that meteor hitting

02:01

the earth in fact is one of the things that professional portfolio manager

02:05

thinks about when building their fund and if you want to do something a little

02:08

more realistic than a meteor what about some crazy dictator and [Rocket appears in the sky]

02:12

Korea nuking us yeah not like one in a gazillion chance probably well more

02:17

recent event was the near-death experience of the US financial system in

02:21

the 2008/09 mortgage crisis where trust in banks and the banking system

02:25

almost led to the bankruptcy of Goldman Sachs Bank of America JP Morgan and a

02:29

bunch of other formerly perceived as bulletproof financial institutions yes

02:34

there was an event and a whole lot of risk and we almost died

02:37

financially anyway eventually the capital markets worked investors came to

02:42

trust the system again and they invested their money in the stock market with [Cash piles up]

02:45

staggering results in that the stock market went up some 400 percent in the

02:50

decade after the financial crisis so events are a real thing you have to

02:55

think about them until you don't [Man falling to the ground on a rocket]

Up Next

Finance: What is Counterparty Risk?
9 Views

What is Counterparty Risk? Counterparty risk is the risk to either party within a transaction that the other will not or be unable to abide by the...

Finance: What are Systematic and Unsystematic Risk?
14 Views

What are systematic and unsystematic risk? Take a risk on this video and hit play.

Finance: What is risk premium?
0 Views

What is risk premium? Risk premium is the amount of excess return or yield that a bond must pay in order to compensate for the additional default r...

Find other enlightening terms in Shmoop Finance Genius Bar(f)